Review of “Urchin of the Riding Stars” (Mistmantle Chronicles)

The Mistmantle Chronicles Book 1: Urchin of the Riding Stars

A mouthful of a title, but don’t be turned off! This book is absolutely worthy of a place in your family library. If you have kids who love Redwall, The Wingfeather Saga, or The Chronicles of Narnia, they’re sure to love this thrilling introduction to the world of Mistmantle.

What is Mistmantle?

An island inhabited by talking squirrels, otters, and hedgehogs! These furry (and prickly) animals live in harmony- until some of the animals become power hungry. Betrayal, manipulation, a puppet king, and a eugenics program ensue.

But on the good side: we have courageous and lovable heroes like Padra the Otter, Crispin the squirrel, and the small but not insignificant eponymous hero of the tale, Urchin. Urchin is a young squirrel with a loyal and true heart. Found as an orphan, he is accepted and loved by the good animals on Mistmantle.

Good and Evil: the Lines are Drawn

This a straightforward black and white, good versus evil, story. The good characters in Mistmantle are heroes, both young and old. The villains are black-hearted and epitomize much of what we see wrong in our secular world: hunger for power and wealth, hatred, and disrespect for human life.

This is one of the most pro-life books I’ve read in a long time, without being didactic at all. The “bad guys” decide that any animals born with birth defects such as poor vision or misshapen claws should be “culled.” As Urchin realizes this means killing newborn baby animals, he recoils in horror and then determines to join the animal underground which hides and raises these defenseless babies.

Crispin, Padra, Urchin, and their friends decide that they must defend the helpless and restore truth and order to the island of Mistmantle.

Spiritual Evil

But what is the dark evil stirring below the castle of Mistmantle? In addition to the obvious plotting of the bad animals, Urchin encounters a spiritual evil deep under the surface of Mistmantle. The evil is awakened by a power-hungry villain, and both fuels and devours him. Who can help? Urchin realizes only the priest of Mismantle can cleanse the island by prayer and fasting. Goosebumps!

Although this is not a Catholic series per se, there are many Catholic elements such as praying to “the Heart” that protects Mistmantle, wise priests, sorcery clearly portrayed as evil, and pro-life lessons.

Sensitive Reader Warning

Now as awesome as this book was, some sensitive children will definitely be upset by the beginning: Urchin’s mother dies giving birth to him. Then later in the book, it’s upsetting to contemplate the “culling” of the newborn disabled baby animals. There’s a lot of tension about whether the bad animals will discover the hiding place of the disabled young ones. And the author does a phenomenal job describing the scary demon haunting the depths of the island. So, for context, my 9 year old who is not particularly sensitive said the beginning was sad, but overall loved this book. But with my more sensitive kids, I’d wait a couple more years. If they’ve already read Redwall, they’ll be fine with this too. The reading level is simpler than Redwall, for context there. Know your kids’ individual needs as always!

The Mistmantle Chronicles series

I’m working through the rest of the series which are fittingly awesome sequels so far. Will update when I’ve read them all.

For now, you can buy Urchin of the Riding Stars from small business publisher Purple House Press or through my Amazon affiliate link.

If you’d like to support Good Books for Catholic Kids, please check out my Patreon Page!

ancient arch architecture art

Review of “The Haunted Cathedral

haunted cathedral cover by kolenc

The Haunted Cathedral

The second installment in Antony Barone Kolenc’s The Hardwood Mysteries, The Haunted Cathedral picks up right where we left Xan at the end of The Shadow in the Dark. This fast-paced historical fiction trilogy set in Middle Age England follows the adventures and misadventures of young Xan, an orphaned boy trying to find his family- and God’s will. In Shadows in the Dark, Xan tries to recover his memory after a group of bandits leaves him wounded and burns his home. In this second book, The Haunted Cathedral, Xan struggles to learn how to forgive and move on. A little mystery might be just what he needs to help distract him from his hatred.

Meticulous Historical Fiction

I really appreciate the care Kolenc takes to accurately represent Middle Age England. From monasteries to towns to castles to cathedrals, Kolenc takes the reader on a tour of what life was like for an orphaned serf boy in the Middle Ages. Speaking of serfs, these books subtly explore the relationships between serfs and lords, monasteries and patrons, merchants and monks. The intricate castes of the Middle Ages get attention in this book as Xan realizes that as a serf he doesn’t have the freedom to choose a vocation or even where to live.

In keeping with the setting, there are some fundamental lifestyle differences. For example, 12 and 14 year old children are already considering courtship, which is of course strange to our modern sensibilities. Xan’s interest in the girls is handled very gently and discreetly though. Kolenc includes a section at the back of the book which outlines many of the unique traditions of the Middle Ages for readers.

An Intriguing Mystery

What are ghosts? Xan and his friends Lucy, Simon, and Christina are fascinated by tales of a ghost in the Cathedral. A wise monk and priest give the different Catholic perspectives on ghosts. In the end, Xan realizes that trying to reconnect with his parents through a ghost isn’t the wisest idea. Instead, he and his friends help solve the Cathedral mystery and restore another orphan to his parents.

A Fresh Catholic Series

It’s fun to see new Catholic historical fiction getting published. Parents will appreciate the discussion questions in the beginning and historical enrichment at the end. Best of all, this series takes on a slippery topic- the Church in the Middle Ages- with an honest and unapologetic tone. There are very good monks, and troubled monks. There are pros and cons to the power the Church and its ministers held in that time period. These are good reflections for the intended tween and teen audience to begin to consider.

You can buy The Hardwood Mysteries: The Haunted Cathedral through my Amazon affiliate link: The Haunted Cathedral

Or through my BookShop page: The Haunted Cathedral

I received a copy of The Haunted Cathedral from Loyola Press in exchange for my honest and unbiased review.